Why did Apple use Graphene instead Samsung’s Vapor Chamber?
Apple and Samsung have taken different approaches to solving overheating issues in their smartphones. With the release of the iPhone 16, Apple opted for Graphene thermal pads, while Samsung continues to use the vapor chamber cooling system in its devices. So, why did Apple choose graphene sheets over the more complex vapor chamber solution? The reasons lie in cost, size, weight, and efficiency.
See the complete thermal datasheet by clicking here: Graphite Sheets
Table of Contents
The Advantages of Graphene Sheets
1. Lower Cost and Smaller Size
Graphene thermal pads offer a significant advantage in terms of cost. Graphene is relatively inexpensive to produce compared to vapor chambers, making it a more economical option for mass production. Additionally, graphene sheets are incredibly thin and lightweight, allowing Apple to save valuable internal space in the iPhone, which is critical for small, lightweight devices like smartphones.
2. Lightweight and Flexible
In comparison to vapor chambers, graphene sheets are much lighter. In mobile devices, every gram matters. The external casing of the iPhone acts as the primary heat sink, as it is in direct contact with the cool external air, which helps dissipate heat. Using a bulky vapor chamber inside a smartphone is unnecessary when the casing already plays a major role in cooling. Additionally, graphene sheets are flexible and can be easily molded or cut into various shapes, allowing them to fit seamlessly into the complex internal structure of modern smartphones.
3. Electromagnetic Shielding
One of the key benefits of graphene thermal pads is their ability to provide electromagnetic shielding. Not only do they conduct heat effectively, but they also reduce electromagnetic interference between internal components. This dual function enhances the overall stability and performance of the iPhone.
The Drawbacks of Vapor Chambers
1. Reliance on Thermal Interface Materials (TIM)
Vapor chambers require additional thermal interface materials (TIM) to transfer heat from the chip to the heat sink. This adds complexity and cost to the cooling system, as more components are needed to ensure effective heat dissipation. In contrast, graphene thermal pads combine the functions of a heat sink and thermal interface, simplifying the overall design while maintaining efficient heat transfer.
2. High Cost and Overengineering
While vapor chambers can provide high levels of cooling efficiency, they come with a higher price tag and may be considered over-engineered for smartphones. In lightweight mobile devices like smartphones, the external casing is primarily responsible for dissipating heat by making contact with cool air. Installing a high-cost vapor chamber inside the device may not significantly improve performance compared to more affordable and efficient alternatives like graphene thermal pads.
Graphene vs. Vapor Chamber: A Closer Comparison
UTVC vs. Graphene
Samsung has also been developing Ultra-Thin Vapor Chamber (UTVC) technology, which offers even better heat transfer than traditional graphite. However, when compared to graphene, UTVC still falls short in some key areas. Graphene is thinner, lighter, and cheaper, making it ideal for smartphones where every millimeter counts. It can be used in spaces as under 0.25mm, making it a superior choice for compact devices like the iPhone.
Conclusion: Why Apple Chose Graphene
Apple’s decision to use Graphene sheets over vapor chambers in the iPhone comes down to practicality. For lightweight mobile devices, graphene offers a more cost-effective, flexible, and space-efficient solution. The material’s excellent thermal conductivity, combined with its ability to provide electromagnetic shielding, makes it an ideal choice for smartphone cooling systems. While vapor chambers, particularly advanced versions like UTVC, can outperform graphite in some areas, they are often over-engineered and less suited for the slim, compact designs of modern smartphones.
In the future, we may see further advancements in graphene technology, which could solidify its position as the go-to material for thermal management in electronics, leaving heavier and more expensive solutions like vapor chambers behind.
As Apple continues to refine its product designs, Graphene Thermal pads offer a forward-looking solution for managing heat in the next generation of mobile devices, ensuring that users can enjoy high-performance smartphones without the risk of overheating or sacrificing sleek, lightweight designs.
LiPOLY TIM Technology : Thermal Solutions